Deliciously Sweet Syrup: Is Mrs. Butterworth Vegan?
In the syrup aisle at your local grocery store, you’re probably familiar with the sight of Mrs. Butterworth. This delicious syrup has been a staple at breakfast tables for decades, but can vegans enjoy this sweet treat? After all, Mrs. Butterworth isn’t necessarily a staple of vegan diets. Let’s take a closer look at this popular syrup to answer the question of whether Mrs. Butterworth is vegan or not.
What is Mrs. Butterworth?
Mrs. Butterworth is a syrupy product produced by Pinnacle Foods. It first appeared in grocery stores in 1961. The product is available in both original and sugar-free versions and comes in bottles featuring a comforting grandmotherly figure. It is made primarily from corn syrup, high fructose corn syrup, and natural flavorings.
What About the Ingredients?
The ingredients list on Mrs. Butterworth’s original syrup lists corn syrup, high fructose corn syrup, water, and natural and artificial flavorings. The sugar-free version also contains maltitol, cellulose gum, and salt. Most of these ingredients would be considered vegan-friendly. The key question is whether or not the artificial flavorings are derived from animal sources.
Are the Flavorings Animal-Derived?
The exact ingredients used in the artificial flavorings are not listed on the product label. However, Pinnacle Foods does share that the artificial flavors are gluten-free, which typically indicates that they are not animal-derived.
What About the Sugar?
In addition to high fructose corn syrup, Mrs. Butterworth’s original syrup contains sugar. There is some debate regarding the vegan-friendliness of sugar, as traditionally it has been processed using bone char. Bone char is a form of activated charcoal made from the bones of cows, although some sugar producers are now using other forms of filtering and bleaching.
What About the Celulose Gum?
The sugar-free version of Mrs. Butterworth contains cellulose gum, an ingredient derived from either wood pulp or cotton linter. While cellulose is derived from plants, some products may use an animal-derived form of cellulose. It is unclear whether the cellulose gum used in Mrs. Butterworth is animal-derived or not.
While the artificial flavorings used in Mrs. Butterworth syrup are likely plant-based, the sugar and cellulose gum used in the product may or may not be vegan. As such, it is difficult to definitively say whether or not Mrs. Butterworth is vegan. Those wanting to stick to a vegan diet should be sure to research all of the ingredients used in the product and contact the manufacturer if necessary.
Alternatives to Mrs. Butterworth
If you want to enjoy the sweet taste of syrup but would rather stick to vegan-friendly products, there are plenty of vegan-friendly alternatives to Mrs. Butterworth. The Maple Grove Farms line of syrups is free of animal products and made with real maple syrup. Aunt Jemima also makes a vegan-friendly maple syrup. For those looking for something a little different, Travers Sweet Co. makes a range of interesting flavors, including peach, cherry, and mandarin orange.
Vegan Recipe Ideas
Syrup doesn’t just have to be limited to pancakes. There are plenty of delicious vegan recipes that use syrup, including waffles, French toast, scones, oatmeal, and yogurt parfaits. You can even get creative with savory dishes such as tempeh bacon and Brussel sprouts with vegan-friendly syrup.
Making Your Own Syrup
For an even more vegan-friendly option, you can also make your own syrup. All you need are some simple ingredients such as maple syrup, coconut sugar, and vanilla extract. To get started, simply mix the ingredients together in a saucepan and simmer until thickened. You can also experiment with different flavors by adding spices such as cinnamon, nutmeg, and allspice to the mix.
The Bottom Line
In conclusion, it is difficult to definitively say whether Mrs. Butterworth is vegan or not. While the artificial flavorings are likely vegan-friendly, the sugar and cellulose gum used in the product may or may not be vegan. If you want to stick to a vegan diet, you may want to look for alternative vegan-friendly syrups or make your own with vegan-friendly ingredients.
I’m Brooke, and I love being vegan. I know all there is to know about the vegan lifestyle, and I love sharing that knowledge with others.
I own a vegan restaurant in Boston, and I love helping people make the switch to a plant-based diet. It’s not always easy, but it’s definitely worth it!